Why does Jesus compare confronting sin to searching for a lost sheep? What does it mean to "win your brother" rather than simply call out what's wrong? And how can the church hold people accountable while leading with love? In today's episode, Jensen unpacks Matthew 18:10–20 and shows us how confronting sin is meant to restore people, not reject them.
Want to become a more consistent Bible reader? Download our free Ten Minute Bible Guide and start building a simple, sustainable habit of...
Read More »Why does Jesus compare confronting sin to searching for a lost sheep? What does it mean to "win your brother" rather than simply call out what's wrong? And how can the church hold people accountable while leading with love? In today's episode, Jensen unpacks Matthew 18:10–20 and shows us how confronting sin is meant to restore people, not reject them.
Want to become a more consistent Bible reader? Download our free Ten Minute Bible Guide and start building a simple, sustainable habit of meeting with God through his word. Grab your guide here.
Read the Bible with us! We're almost done exploring the Gospels—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—but it's never too late to jump in! Download your reading plan now.
Your support makes TMBT possible. Ten Minute Bible Talks is a crowd-funded project. Join the TMBTeam to reach more people with the Bible. Give now.
Like this content? Make sure to leave us a rating and share it so that others can find it, too. Use #asktmbt to connect with us, ask questions, and suggest topics. We'd love to hear from you!
To learn more, visit our website and follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter @TenMinuteBibleTalks.
Don't forget to subscribe to the TMBT Newsletter here.
Passage: Matthew 18:10-20
Welcome to Ten Minute Bible Talks, where we connect the Bible to your life in the time it takes to get to work. I'm Jensen Holt McNair.
Church discipline. It's not a particularly fun topic to think about, right? Excommunication, confrontation, calling out sin. I'd honestly rather not. But today has left me no choice and so we're going to do our best. Now, I do think that the majority of my hesitation and maybe yours too revolves around the way that people talk about and perceive this topic. To confront someone in their sin, who are you to judge? To cast someone out of the church? Isn't God all about welcome and love? We live in a world of acceptance, the world of let them. Opposite this, we also live in the world of cancel culture. When someone does something we deem grievous enough, they're done, cut off, no longer accepted in society.
And we know how it feels to be confronted. Like we know the shame. There's a popular TV show depicting a man who has been canceled by culture and who had committed serious crimes, but he's tormented by his shame, the weight of his sin and the words of others condemning him. It's all going through his mind right before he's shown kind of accepting his death when he doesn't intervene, when he realizes that his car is heading off a cliff in the dark of night. You see, the shame of his sin of the confrontation led him to desperation. He was tormented by it and resigned to die rather than live a life trying to wade the waters of cancel culture.
See, the complexity of the moment has not been lost on me and I've thought about that moment in that show often. On the one hand, we want justice for sins, for crimes, for true evil. On the other hand, we bristle at the idea of a church that would hold a line against sin and condemn others. We're both willing to dole out our own judgment in certain cases and empathize with the one who has sinned when we can see our own faults, feel our own shame. That small voice comes back. Who are you to judge? It's why we get defensive. It's why we hide our sin. It's why we don't want to be confronted to face our shame.
But Jesus is very clear in our passage today. He is concerned about sin and he's clear about what we are to do with it. OK, but before we get too uncomfortable or upset about what's coming, I want us to notice some key details from the text that's going to kind of help us sort out this complicated relationship that we have with confrontation. Now first, the passage talking about dealing with sin follows on the heels of a parable, the parable of the lost sheep. In this parable we see the shepherd, who's Jesus, desperately going out in search of the lost sheep, seeking him out, restoring him to the fold, rejoicing at his return. We learn that the Father is not willing to let any of his little ones, those who have wandered, those who are in sin, those who are weak.
To perish. He's not willing to let any of them perish. So the stage is set. Jesus cares about those who stray because he loves them, because he wishes to see them restored back into his family, to keep them safe. See, the why behind confrontation is not to condemn, not to push someone out, but to welcome them in. There's further confirmation of this when in the next verse, while Jesus is telling us how to confront sin, he says to go and do so in order that you would win them over. Other translations say so that you would gain your brother. See, the goal, the why of confrontation is so that you might gain back your brother.
The second thing to note is the term brother. See, Jesus isn't talking about confronting those outside the church. This is not about confronting culture. This is not about confronting a nonbeliever. This is confrontation within the church body for the sake of the church. So already our premise differs from many of our hesitations origins. We cannot merely accept sin as the world often would have us do. When the one who is sinning is our brother, someone who professes to follow Jesus, it is not loving to let him wander. The shepherd doesn't say, if he wants to go off, he can. It's what he wants. He knows where that sheep belongs. He knows there is safety there, love there, community, flourishing. He was made. To be a part of his fold.
So he goes out and seeks him and brings him home. He shows him love by guiding him back into the fold. See, confrontation is loving when it's done with gentleness and wisdom. So let's look more at what this confrontation looks like. First, it's private and it's immediate. We don't wait for the offender to come to us. We don't wait for the offender to apologize first. We don't gossip about it first. We go to our brother first and hopefully they listen. They hear us out and they enter back into the fold. But if not, the verses tell us that we bring a few more people in to bear witness, but also to help us discern if the confrontation is valid, to help all parties see the sin and acknowledge it together.
See, this is a mercy because I know I am quick to be defensive. I am quick to be proud. Part of bringing another person in would humble me, but Jesus has made it clear over the last few chapters that it is the humble who come to Jesus in their need. You see, it's the little ones who seek Jesus out, who have a special place in the heart of God. Now finally, yes, if that doesn't work, you bring it before the whole church. Verse 17. If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church. If he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.
OK, so Jesus is kind of giving churches authority to judge here to make a call. If someone doesn't listen, if they continue to dig in, if they continue to reject wise counsel, if even the entire church body confronts them and they do not listen, then let it be as though they are not a part of the church. So the understanding is that someone who understands the gospel, who desires to live in the fold of God, who has the Holy Spirit moving inside of them would humbly accept the confrontation. would listen if an entire church body agrees on and sees their sin. Now, we live in a fallen world with fallen churches, and there are times when people are condemned on the basis of things that are not clear commandments of the Lord, people who are unjustly convicted.
And at the same time, there are churches that fail to confront, that leave sins hidden for too long, that fail to bring them to the light to allow their church body to call out the sin. We cannot escape these tragedies and we cannot condone these misuses of confrontation. What we can do is remain faithful to the call of Jesus. We can be people who follow Jesus's commands, who value knowing scripture and understanding what we are called to as believers so that we can discern when confrontation is truly needed. We can be people who desperately desire out of love for our brothers and sisters to remain in the fold of Jesus, who seek them out even if it requires the difficult process of confrontation.
See, I think that if we're faithful in these ways, then we become part of changing the narrative. We become churches and communities that are unwilling to allow sin and evil to flourish inside the church walls hidden by piety, pride, and an unwillingness to rock the boat. We become churches that desire to live in line with Jesus's teachings, that become comfortable with confrontation, that are sanctified by it, made more holy, more in line with Jesus's vision for the church. We become more comfortable both receiving confrontation and confronting sin. And in doing so, we root out the shame that lives in so many hearts. The fear of being found out because we recognize the goal, the delight that God feels when a straying sheep is brought into the fold, the understanding that the shepherd will always seek you out, not to condemn you and put you on trial, but to remind you he already stood trial for your sin in your places beside him as his beloved child.
When we look to Jesus, look to what he calls us to, look to his desires, his hopes, his joy for his people, we get a picture of healthy confrontation, one rooted in love, in restoration for the sake of the lost, not to condemn, but to sanctify, refine and restore the church body.
God, would you give us courage, wisdom, and discernment? May we be gentle in rebuke. May we be motivated by love. May our goal always be to restore. May we rejoice as you do when the lost return. May we remain humble in heart, knowing that as long as we are humans and members of the church, we will fall short too. God, bring people into our own lives with the courage, wisdom and discernment needed to confront us, to help bring us back into the fold and to sanctify us. God, would you protect us from the misuse of confrontation? Would we only use it to refine, to grow, to bless your church? God, we love you. We love your church. May that be our guide in all things and at all times.
Add a little more Bible to your life with this weekly newsletter. Each week, you'll get to take a deeper dive into some aspect of the Bible passages discussed on Ten Minute Bible Talks, the devotional podcast. Explore the Bible, find spiritual encouragement, and learn how to develop a deeper connection with God.